There is a huge qualitative difference between these two statements:
“I’m sorry you’re upset.”
and
“I’m sorry I upset you.”
There is also a major difference between these statements:
“I’m sorry I upset you.”
and
“I’m sorry I did this thing that upset you.”
I’d love to get the very last sort of apology. It’s what I got out of nowhere from Alice and it made me feel deeply humble and human and appreciated. But there is a damn lot of value in the middle sort of apology. It is the sort of apology that keeps friendships afloat. I have offered more of the middle and last sort of apologies to Christina than I can count; I’m not perfect or blameless in any way, and I am absolutely sorry for all of the things I did that contributed to her decision to end our friendship.
I am not sorry for wanting a real apology for having been hurt. Adults own up when they hurt someone else and apologize for causing hurt, even if they think their actions were perfectly right.
I am deeply, unfathomably sorry that the people I thought were my best friends of seven years would rather end that friendship than tell me they’re sorry.
It’s been an interesting week.
Yesterday I quit my job, the one I didn’t like and had to drive an hour each way to do. I have interviews scheduled and a lot of hope, and a lot of horrible anxiety, which is why I now have vanilla coke. It helps.
Thursday and Friday, I exchanged emails with Stina which curiously involved me apologizing an awful lot and her not at all, because I very strongly value having her as my friend even if she isn’t a nice person (1). I also learned from Kitty that generalizing lessons about emotional intimacy is probably a good move. Huh. Anyway, this led to an awful lot of sobbing and feeling pretty much like I must be broken in some way to not be able to sustain my friendships from college. And that led to…
Opening an email from Alice. It’s been sitting in my inbox, marked as read, for just over four months. I didn’t open it originally because it was two days before I started my new job (which turned out terribly anyway) and I might not make a personality disorder out of it, but I can certainly be avoidant. I didn’t open it later because it’d been a long time. Then I didn’t open it out of habit. So I opened it, and it was a very long, beautiful, heartbreaking apology letter (I habitually distrust email subject lines, so the fact that it said it was an apology didn’t convince me). It was everything I would love to get from Stina and Dylan and don’t really expect.
So then I cried some more. And then my job was over and I slept for ages. And then I went to the farmer’s market with my mom and we bonded (! I KNOW!) over apparently being unable to make our loved ones feel emotionally connected to us because we are demonstrative sort of people, not declarative, and apparently that makes people really annoyed. And then I wrote a blog post about it using really terrible grammar.
AND THEN I DECLARED THAT I AM A ROBOT MADE OUT OF MUSCLE.
And then it was over. Except for a footnote.
1. I would like to know why it’s okay to say that when we’re friends, but not when we’re fighting. I genuinely do not understand the difference. I’m expressing the exact same sentiment, but it was hilarious once and now apparently elicits tears.
It’s slow, this process. Change passwords, make previously open things private. Extricate myself from your life one photo at a time.
I cry, sometimes without warning or explanation. I am relieved, grateful when my coworkers say they’ll miss me, give me phone numbers and talk of a party. Parties terrify me; I loathe them to the depths of my being, but they don’t have to know any of that because I appreciate the consideration. None of them are friends, but they’re nice enough people.
We talked about that, once. Friendship was an exclusive club to the two of us, something we extended rarely and selectively. We talked about how valuable it was, and how glad we were to have found each other. I believed every word of it.
I believed every word of it. You told me, so it must be true.
I doubt you think of me, or miss me, or have any regrets. Spending a day with your husband (and his friend) was more important than seeing someone who had been your best friend of seven years, at considerable expense and travel on my part. You’ve never seen where I live. Coming to me has never been an option. I’m only worth your time if I show up and do what you want me to do.
And fuck you, because I would forgive you if you fucking asked. If you had the decency to write and say you missed me, you’re sorry, any gesture of reconcilliation or apology, I would fall over myself to forgive you, because you are my best friend of seven years and I hate not having you in my life. Even though my family have told me time and again that you are not worth my effort or love or trust.
You’re not a nice person. I hope someday you realize it, and feel bad.
I stopped being friends with Alice when she blew me off.
Alice and I met within days of starting at Mary Baldwin. We auditioned for and joined the Madrigals together, and just hit it off immediately–similar senses of humour, both smart and curious about the world, and rather similar politics (though her Catholic homeschooled background made it hard for her to admit she was liberal, let alone progressive). She was one of my very best friends for the three years I was in college. There were regular rumours we were dating, we were so close.
I left and went to Australia and my girlfriend (much to Alice’s annoyance) and tried to keep up our friendship. I wrote in my then-blog, I wrote emails, I called a handful of times. The burden of maintenance was mine, but it was okay: I’d get back to the US and see her again and our friendship would properly pick up where we left off.
Except that it didn’t.
Alice and I made plans as soon as I knew I’d be back in town. Kitty was with me. We’d meet for coffee and catch up and everything would be great again. But Alice didn’t come for coffee; she blew off our date entirely to make an “emergency” trip for cold medicine for her (adult, able bodied, car-owning) roommate and then never rescheduled.
I put my foot down. Alice had blown off small things with me in college, and I’d always forgiven it. I knew that I liked more concrete plans than she did, and that she had many friends who were cooler than I was, so there was always a chance of being left for a better time. At the end of our second year, she decided unilaterally we shouldn’t be friends anymore since I was just going to leave anyway and she was bad at keeping up friendships; it was only after I pleaded to keep my best friend that we stayed close for the last year. Being ignored to baby the person she lived with was the last straw for me, and I cut Alice out of my life. We’ve exchanged emails once since then, which were unproductive, and she emailed me in September. I haven’t opened it. It’s been two and a half years since I lost my best friend.
Stina and Dylan were there when we fought: Kitty and I were staying at their house on that trip to Staunton, before I moved back to my college town. They were there when Alice and I fought over email–hell, Dylan was the one who opened the first email for me and read it, so he could warn me if I wanted to read it or not.
I’ve known Stina and Dylan since about a week into my first semester at Mary Baldwin. We met when I joined the queer/feminist group on campus, which Dylan and I would eventually co-run. They were my other best friends, complimentary matches for me and each other. It was a little easier to keep up with them when I moved, because calling one meant getting both, and they opened their house up without hesitation for us when Kitty and I arrived in the US. They invited me to live with them while I figured out what the hell I was going to DO with my life.
I don’t know how to write the collapse of our friendship. It’s raw and it hurts and none of the paragraphs I’ve started in this space are accurate.
I felt left out, ignored. I saw patterns in their treatment of me that made my heart ache with loneliness. I watched them each grow more unkind and reassure each other that it wasn’t so. I felt entirely unrespected. I couldn’t talk about it, too afraid to bring up small hurts but dwelling on them endlessly until they became big hurts and then I’d explode. But by then they’d forgotten the small hurts and I was making something out of nothing. For a psych major, Dylan is fucking terrible at introspection.
I was told, explicitly, that I was not autistic because i didn’t match his expectations of what an autistic person should be. I was told I was a lesbian, and any attempts to restate my actual identity were dismissed as trivial. I was told that genderqueer people don’t exist or are just indecisive. I was told I was petty, and rude, and embarassing to take out in public. I was told I was mean and hateful. I remember every fucking word that was said to me. They inform my self esteem and my sense of who I am and sow seeds of doubt deep into my heart.
We fought again and again. My therapist told me they were poisonous, no good for me.
I wish I’d listened to her. I wish I’d been able to listen to her. I defended them vigorously and angrily. How dare she say that about my only local friends?
I moved away in April. It was for the best; they hurt me again and again and while nothing seemed to change on their side, I felt broken and tired. I ended up here. I saw them in September for their wedding.
“Come for Thanksgiving. We miss you!”
So I asked off for Thanksgiving. I asked when they wanted me to come up. Two weeks ago they broke it to me: I’d be welcome to come, but they had no guest bed and were planning to spend black friday on a prolonged date.
Wait. So I’m welcome to come up, but I have to spend one of 3 days with them by myself because I am less important than them–married to each other, living together–having a date.
I didn’t go. They got their black friday together. I got time to myself without being touched and harassed and quiet. Lots of quiet.
“Dylan Grey had an awesome black fridate. All of my shopping is done. ALMOST. Lovely day with Christina Scott Sayer Grey, with delightful guest appearance by Megan Kolano. Tangled was GREAT. Bella is cuddly. Dylan out!”
They let a friend join them after all.
I think this is the point where I say I’m done.
but lately, part of me just crumbles
every time I hear that melody
I have not gotten into the choir for which I auditioned. This is an unprecedented thing, with the exception of a middle school all-state choir that I knew I wasn’t getting into in the first place. I don’t know how to react to it. I was counting on that choir to be a place where I could make friends. A friend. One would be nice.
There’s a choir here in town that I would love to be a part of, but whose audition requirements essentially make it impossible for someone like me to join. I’m not being euphemistic about autsim stuff, though–I’m talking about musical experience. I am a chorister. I don’t sing solo pieces and never have. So requiring that I have a prepared aria means, well, I won’t even audition, because I have no means of preparing; my sheet music reading skills are substandard for the sort of music I’m capable of performing. Further, I’ll own that my voice often sounds reedy and thin alone, but I can bolster a chorus and blend well–and how can a director tell that from me doing a solo piece? Surely one doesn’t want a chorus entirely made of strong soloist voices? There need to be those like me who can shift from part to part and provide a depth of cover.
I hate it here.
My name is Ali, though sometimes it's Eliot.
I have many tumblrs, which you are welcome to also visit:
The Polite Yeti - My personal tumblr, full of silliness.
Fuck Yeah, Kate Miller-Heidke - the only active Kate fan site, which is baffling.
The Branden Rose - the only active Monster Blood Tattoo fansite, which is less baffling.
I also have a semi-successful etsy shop, which you should visit, below.
Please buy things from me:
A brief history:
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009